Myth: a 640 FICO score (the credit score from Fair Isaac Corporation) shuts you out of a conventional refinance. Reality: Fannie Mae removed its fixed 620 minimum for loans run through Desktop Underwriter (DU), its automated approval system, for files created from November 16, 2025. Your score now shapes price and eligibility case by case instead of ending the application at the door.
In an FHA vs conventional refinance at a 640 FICO, loan-to-value (LTV) usually decides the cheaper loan. FHA charges mortgage insurance for 11 years or the full term, while conventional private mortgage insurance can be removed once the balance falls to 80% of the home's original value. Compare five-year total cost, not just the rate.
The Federal Housing Administration (FHA) still sets its own floor. Under HUD Mortgagee Letter 2026-11, a decision credit score of 580 or higher allows refinance financing up to 97.75% of value, while a score of 500 to 579 caps it at 90%. A 640 clears that bar. The real question is what each loan charges you for being there.
FHA vs Conventional Refinance at a Glance
| Feature | FHA refinance | Conventional refinance |
|---|---|---|
| Credit floor | 580 for up to 97.75% financing; 500 to 579 capped at 90% | No fixed minimum in DU for files created from November 16, 2025 |
| Upfront insurance | 1.75% of the base loan | No FHA-style upfront premium |
| Annual insurance (30-year loan up to $726,200) | 0.50% at 95% LTV or below; 0.55% above 95% | Private mortgage insurance (PMI), priced by the insurer, for equity under 20% |
| How long it lasts | 11 years at 90% LTV or below; full term above 90% | Removable at 80%; automatic at 78% if payments are current |
For a wider cost comparison without the credit-score focus, read FHA vs Conventional Refinance: Which Costs Less Now?
Why Loan-to-Value Matters More Than Your Score Here
LTV is your loan balance divided by the home's appraised value. A $270,000 balance on a $300,000 home is 90% LTV.
HUD's FHA premium schedule has no credit-score input. It varies by loan term, loan size and LTV only. On a 30-year loan of $726,200 or less, the annual premium is 0.50% when LTV is 95% or below and 0.55% above 95%. It lasts 11 years at 90% LTV or below, and the full loan term above that (HUD Mortgagee Letter 2023-05).
Conventional insurance works differently. Under the Homeowners Protection Act, as the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) describes it, you can request PMI cancellation when the balance is scheduled to reach 80% of original value, and it must end automatically at 78% if you are current. Analysis: FHA insurance ends on a fixed date or lasts the loan's life, while conventional insurance ends when your equity does.
Rate Backdrop: What the Fed and Freddie Mac Show
Freddie Mac's survey put the 30-year fixed average at 7.11% as of November 12, 2026, against 6.24% a year earlier. Read it as a national benchmark, not a 640 FICO quote.
The Federal Reserve held its target range at 3.75% to 4% on October 28, 2026, by a 10 to 2 vote. Both dissenters wanted a quarter-point increase. Rate outlook: uncertain, and I won't forecast it.
Worked Example (US): Marcus Compares Both Loans at 90% LTV
Hypothetical. Marcus has a 640 FICO, a $270,000 balance and a $300,000 appraisal, so LTV is 90%. These inputs are assumed, not market quotes: FHA at 6.75%, conventional at 7.25%, PMI at 1.20% a year, both 30-year fixed, identical closing costs.
Formula: monthly payment = P × i ÷ (1 − (1 + i)^−360), where i is the annual rate divided by 12.
- FHA: upfront premium $270,000 × 1.75% = $4,725, added to the balance for $274,725. Payment at 6.75%: $1,781.86. Annual premium: $270,000 × 0.50% ÷ 12 = $112.50. Total: $1,894.36 a month.
- Conventional: $270,000 at 7.25%: $1,841.88. PMI: $270,000 × 1.20% ÷ 12 = $270.00. Total: $2,111.88 a month.
Five-year cost counts interest plus insurance, because principal repaid stays your equity. The example applies the premium rate to the starting balance for simplicity.
- FHA: $90,086.71 interest + $6,750.00 premiums + $4,725.00 upfront = $101,561.71.
- Conventional: $95,335.26 interest + $16,200.00 PMI = $111,535.26.
Result: FHA costs $9,974 less over five years on these inputs.
Threshold test: holding PMI constant, the conventional rate must fall to about 6.52% to tie, which is 0.23 points below FHA's assumed rate. On its schedule, this PMI would reach the 80% mark in month 104, about eight years and eight months in. FHA's premium would run 132 months.
Hypothetical, second case. Renata has the same score and home but owes $240,000, so LTV is 80%. FHA adds $4,200 upfront and $100 a month in premiums. Its five-year cost at the assumed 6.75% is $90,277.08. A conventional loan with no PMI ties at 7.71%, which is 0.96 points above FHA. The same score produced opposite answers because equity changed.
When Each Loan Tends to Win, and What Can Go Wrong
Analysis, not a rule: FHA tends to fit when equity is thin and the conventional quote carries a heavy PMI charge. Conventional tends to fit when equity nears 20%, where PMI disappears and FHA's 1.75% upfront premium becomes pure cost.
Both carry risk:
- FHA adds the upfront premium to your balance, so you owe more on day one.
- FHA premiums last the full term above 90% LTV, which is a long commitment.
- Conventional pricing stays unknown until a lender runs DU against your file.
- Every refinance restarts closing costs and the clock on your break-even.
- Points paid on a refinance are generally deducted ratably over the loan term, according to the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), not all in the year you pay them.
- A quote listing only principal and interest hides the insurance charge.
- Promises of guaranteed approval or a guaranteed lowest rate are red flags.
If you only need cash, a home equity product leaves the first mortgage alone, as HELOC vs Home Equity Loan Rates 2026 Analysis explains. Unsecured borrowing at the same score is a different product, covered in Myth vs Reality: Qualify for Personal Loans at 640 FICO. In the US, complaints go to the CFPB complaint database, your state regulator or your state attorney general.
The UK View: Remortgaging With an Imperfect Credit File
UK readers: this section uses British spelling and UK rules. FHA, FICO and US-style PMI do not apply here.
The Bank of England's Monetary Policy Committee raised Bank Rate from 3.75% to 4% on 5 November 2026. The next decision is 17 December 2026. Bank of England figures show 34,500 remortgaging approvals in July 2026, up from 34,100 in June. Those cover only switches to a different lender, so a product transfer, a new deal with your current lender, is not counted.
British lenders use no single FICO. They check your credit file at agencies such as Experian, Equifax and TransUnion, then apply their own criteria and pricing. The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) regulates mortgage lenders and brokers. If a regulated firm mishandles your case, the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS), a free service set up by Parliament, can look at the complaint.
Check any early repayment charge (ERC), the fee for leaving a fixed deal early, before you switch.
Worked Example (UK): Eleanor's Remortgage Break-Even
Hypothetical. Eleanor owes £200,000 on a £250,000 home, so LTV is 80%, with 20 years left. Assumed inputs: her current rate is 7.00%, a new two-year fix is 5.40%, fees total £1,999, and no ERC applies.
- Current payment: £200,000 at 7.00% over 240 months = £1,550.60.
- New payment: £200,000 at 5.40% over 240 months = £1,364.50.
- Monthly saving: about £186.
- Break-even: £1,999 ÷ £186.09 (unrounded) = 10.7 months, so about 11 months.
- Net over the two-year fix: £186.09 × 24 − £1,999 = about £2,467.
This tests only the fixed period. When the fix ends, the rate resets and the sum changes.
Quote-Comparison Checklist
Gather these before you apply:
- Same-day written FHA and conventional quotes, with insurance shown as its own monthly line.
- Your LTV, from the Lending Logic Lab Loan-to-Value Ratio resource.
- The date your insurance ends: 11 years or full term for FHA, 80% or 78% for PMI.
- Total closing costs and whether you finance them.
- Break-even months, using the Lending Logic Lab Refinance Break-Even resource.
- Your paperwork, via Lending Logic Lab Loan Application Documents.
- UK only: ERC amount, product fee, legal and valuation costs.
Three Things to Remember
- A 640 FICO clears FHA's 580 line, and Fannie Mae's old 620 DU floor no longer blocks it. Price is the fight.
- FHA insurance ends after 11 years only at 90% LTV or below.
- Break-even math beats headline rates: Marcus's gap was $9,974 one way, and Renata's was the opposite.
Test your own numbers: run your last two quotes through the tie test and see which loan wins.
FAQ
Can I refinance with a 640 FICO score?
Yes, under both programs. FHA allows up to 97.75% financing on a refinance at 580 or above, per HUD. Fannie Mae's DU no longer applies a fixed 620 floor to files created from November 16, 2025. Approval and price still depend on income, debt-to-income ratio (DTI, monthly debt divided by gross income) and equity, so get written quotes.
Can I remove PMI after a conventional refinance?
Yes. Ask the servicer to cancel once the balance is scheduled to reach 80% of original value, provided you are current and have a good payment history. PMI must end automatically at 78% if you are current. Extra principal payments can bring the 80% date forward, but they do not move the 78% date, per the CFPB.
Where do I complain about a US refinance lender?
Try the lender's complaint process first, then file with the CFPB complaint database. You can also contact your state financial regulator or attorney general. Keep your Loan Estimate, rate-lock confirmation and emails. Dated records make a complaint easier to resolve and show regulators exactly what you were quoted, and when.
Does the Bank of England base rate decide my remortgage rate?
Not directly. Bank Rate rose from 3.75% to 4% on 5 November 2026, and tracker deals follow it by design. Lenders price fixed deals themselves, so a later move does not change a rate you have already fixed. The next decision is 17 December 2026, so compare deals now rather than guess the outcome.
Can I switch my UK mortgage without a full affordability check?
Sometimes. FCA policy statement PS19/27, from October 2019, lets lenders choose a modified assessment if you have kept up payments for 12 months, want no extra borrowing beyond fees, and are switching deals on the same property. Ask your lender whether it uses the option before you pay any application fee.
Next Step: Two Quotes and One Tie Test
This week, request one FHA and one conventional written quote at the same LTV. Then run the tie test. Under Marcus's assumptions, a conventional rate at 90% LTV must sit about 0.23 points below FHA's to tie, and at 80% LTV it can sit up to 0.96 points above. Those gaps come from assumed inputs, so rerun them with your real quotes: interest plus monthly insurance times 60 plus any upfront premium. You can read more about the author on the About Me page.
Sources & References
- U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), Mortgagee Letter 2026-11, October 8, 2026. Supports the 580 and 500 to 579 score tiers and the 97.75% and 90% refinance LTV caps.
- HUD, Mortgagee Letter 2023-05, 2023. Supports the annual FHA premium schedule, the $726,200 threshold and the 11-year and full-term durations.
- Homebridge Wholesale, FHA Program Guidelines, August 3, 2026. Secondary source, used because HUD Handbook 4000.1 text was not reachable: supports the 1.75% upfront premium.
- Orrick, Fannie Mae Updates Selling Guide, Removes Minimum Credit Score for Loans Using Desktop Underwriter, November 14, 2025. Supports the DU change for files created from November 16, 2025.
- CFPB, Compliance Bulletin 2015-03, August 4, 2015. Supports the 80% request and 78% automatic PMI termination rules.
- IRS, Topic no. 504, Home mortgage points. Supports ratable deduction of refinance points over the loan term.
- Freddie Mac, Primary Mortgage Market Survey, week of November 12, 2026. Supports the 7.11% and 6.24% averages.
- Federal Reserve, FOMC statement, October 28, 2026. Supports the 3.75% to 4% range and the 10 to 2 vote.
- Bank of England, Bank Rate, 2026. Supports the 4% rate, the 5 November 2026 rise and the 17 December 2026 meeting.
- Bank of England, Money and Credit, July 2026, published 1 September 2026. Supports 34,500 remortgaging approvals.
- FCA, PS19/27, October 2019. Supports the modified affordability assessment conditions.
- Financial Ombudsman Service, Complaints can help, 2026. Supports the description of FOS as a free service.
Disclaimer: This article is educational content, not personalized financial, mortgage, tax or legal advice. Worked examples use assumed inputs and are not rate quotes, and no approval, rate or saving is guaranteed. US and UK rules differ, so do not apply one country's rules to the other. Before you borrow, consult a licensed mortgage broker or adviser, or a regulated comparison service; in the UK, check that the firm is authorised by the FCA.

0 Comments